Gavin’s Goodbye Gift

California has developed a remarkably expensive way of saying, “I thought we had more money.”

On November 18, the state’s nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office projected a $2 billion deficit at the end of 2027–28, with considerably larger shortfalls in the years that follow. That’s its forecast. It also ran a separate scenario in which the stock market crashes in 2027. In that case, annual deficits would exceed $30 billion, and the state’s reserves and borrowing capacity wouldn’t be enough to cover them. In other words, Sacramento has a problem if the market behaves and a much bigger one if it doesn’t.

In June, Gavin Newsom’s office announced no projected deficit for the current budget year or the next and said his administration was leaving California on its “strongest fiscal footing in generations.” Newsom called the budget “structurally sound.” That’s a hell of a thing to put in writing when the next person to look at the books works for the Legislature and doesn’t need an invitation to your farewell party.

In America, Act Your Age, I write about people who acquire adult authority without acquiring the habits that make it safe to give them any. One of those habits is knowing the difference between money you have and money you’re counting on. A kid can spend his birthday money before his birthday. He usually can’t make the neighbors cover the difference. Give him a state budget and suddenly the neighbors are stakeholders.

Here’s what makes the November report so awkward for Newsom.

California’s finances have already benefited from the stock-market boom. The analysts say the AI-driven surge and spending reductions in this year’s budget helped narrow the shortfalls they projected a year ago. After those improvements, there’s still a gap between what the state expects to collect and what it has committed to spend. Sacramento didn’t need bad luck to get into this position. Good luck got it this far.

And we know some of how it got there. In a separate November review, the analyst’s office estimated that General Fund spending rose from $146 billion in 2019–20 to $248 billion in 2026–27. About 70 percent of that increase went toward sustaining existing services. Roughly 30 percent went toward expanding or adding services. In the boom years, lawmakers did direct most surplus money to temporary purposes, but they also approved ongoing commitments. The 2021–22 package alone included new ongoing commitments initially expected to grow from $3.4 billion to $12.4 billion in a few years. A windfall can get you through the ceremony. It has no obligation to come back for the anniversary.

The people relying on those services can’t budget the way politicians do. A family has to figure out who’s picking up the kids from school and what they’ll do if child care gets more expensive. A provider has to decide whether it can hire people and keep paying them. A business that signs a contract has to make payroll whether the people in Sacramento look good on television that week or not. By the time a budget promise becomes unaffordable, somebody has already organized a real life around it. I’m supposed to believe the compassionate thing is to announce the promise and leave the unpleasant questions for whoever takes office next?

I’ve run businesses. When you have an unusually good month, you can enjoy it without immediately inventing a bill you’ll have to pay twelve times a year. You can also spend money on two perfectly sensible things and discover you could only afford one. That’s when you find out whether the person running the business can make a decision. Sacramento calls both things investments and hopes nobody asks when the money’s coming back.

The first question when budgeting is easy: Does somebody need help?

Now keep going. What would actually help? Who pays for it next year? How will you know it worked? What will you stop doing to make room for it? Those questions become impolite in a hurry when somebody has already printed the invitations to the launch. Ask them anyway. You’re more likely to help someone if you know whether you can still be there after the cameras leave.

That’s also why I don’t buy the old line that anyone who questions state spending must be indifferent to the people it serves. If California Democrats believe these programs are essential, they should want to know which ones can hold up in a bad year. Walk Californians through the biggest recurring commitments. Show them what the programs accomplish. Tell them which expansions can wait and what happens to the rest if tax collections disappoint. They went to the trouble of putting “structurally sound” in the announcement. They can go to the trouble of showing their work.

There’s another irony here. California’s progressive politicians can spend a whole afternoon explaining why some people make too much money. Then the state’s budget analysts have to explain what happens when those people don’t make enough. California depends heavily on personal income taxes, and gains tied to a roaring market can turn into generous tax receipts. Sacramento can take credit for the services those receipts buy, but it doesn’t get to decide what investors will earn next year. I’d like to see that part mentioned in the next speech about fiscal stewardship.

The analyst’s office offered a fairly unglamorous prescription.

Start with cautious revenue assumptions. If collections beat expectations, put the extra money into reserves or pay down budgetary debt. Make lasting changes to close the projected gap, and start identifying options for a deeper downturn now. Nobody gets oversized scissors for deciding not to spend a windfall. But when the money isn’t there, the people counting on a service would rather you’d saved the cash than the photo.

Ordinarily, a governor heading out the door would love to have a good market and a treasury benefitting from it. It gives him room to put things in order before the next governor takes over. The adult use of that good fortune is to leave the state with fewer expensive decisions to make when times get worse. The childish use is to pose with the numbers while they flatter you and let the next administration explain what they meant.

A budget projection can change between June and November. Of course it can. That’s precisely why Newsom’s claim of historic fiscal strength deserves a harder look than his press office gave it. You can balance a spending plan on the day you sign it and leave the state exposed to revenue swings that anybody paying attention knows are possible. The signature is real. So are the obligations it leaves. It’s the durability of those obligations, and not the confidence of the guy holding the pen, that ought to determine what we call a success.

shop.thekevinjacksonnetwork.com/product/be-hard-to-fool-white-letter-hoodie

Californians ought to be able to ask what they’re getting for their money without being handed a lecture about their values.

A worker putting off a car repair because the rent went up has already made a choice between two things he needs. He understands that choosing doesn’t make the other expense unimportant. What he has every right to resent is a government that treats the same obligation as optional for itself, then treats his paycheck as the place to make up the difference.

That’s the line I keep coming back to in America, Act Your Age. Growing up means taking responsibility while you still have choices. Waiting until somebody else is stuck with the choices is a neat trick if your only concern is getting out of the room before the bill arrives. It’s a lousy way to run a state, and nobody should confuse it with generosity.

The taxpayers have already supplied the mon

ey. They shouldn’t also have to supply the adults.

Copy */
Back to top button