
America’s universities have a remarkable talent for taking a simple question and hiring enough administrators to make sure nobody can answer it.
Ask whether a student is prepared to succeed, and before long you’re discussing identity categories, institutional commitments, and an acronym that requires its own associate dean. Ask whether the same standards apply to everybody, and you may need to reserve a conference room.
That habit is one reason I wrote America, Act Your Age. A grown-up country should be able to distinguish between helping someone prepare for an opportunity and deciding that the opportunity must be organized around the color of his skin. Those are different propositions, even when they arrive in the same expensive brochure.
On November 12, the Equal Protection Project filed a civil-rights complaint with the Justice Department concerning 30 universities that participate in a consortium connected to the Institute for Recruitment of Teachers. The complaint alleges that participating schools gain access to a race-conscious pool of graduate applicants through the institute and asks federal officials to investigate whether the arrangement violates civil-rights law. An allegation is not a finding, and the universities deserve an examination of what they actually do. But the questions raised are worth asking.
The institute describes its mission as supporting talented, underserved and underrepresented future educators. It also says it selects students from diverse backgrounds, including Asian and white students, who are committed to its ideals. Advising a student, helping her navigate an application, or connecting her with a mentor can be worthwhile. A person who knows the process can save a young applicant a great deal of confusion, and nobody should pretend otherwise.
But when universities make racial disparities and diversity central to how they organize opportunity, they invite a question that a pamphlet cannot answer: Are they helping individual students develop their abilities, or building a system that views those students primarily through the lens of race?

I know the answer the administrators will offer.
They will say the categories are necessary to address disparities. They will point to historical exclusion, and no serious account of American education can pretend that history did not happen. But recognizing that somebody once had a door closed in his face does not require us to spend eternity assigning everybody a different entrance. At some point, we ought to be confident enough in the people we claim to serve to let them walk through the same door and be judged by what they bring into the room.
A bright student from a struggling school may need better preparation. Give him access to rigorous courses, a mentor, information about financial aid, and a clear understanding of what a university expects. If his family has never navigated college admissions, help him learn the process. None of that requires anybody to tell him that his race is the most useful thing about him. In fact, the best help equips him to demonstrate how much he can do without a bureaucrat following him around with a clipboard explaining why he belongs.
Imagine a coach telling a talented young athlete, “I’m going to help you train, study the game, and compete for a position.” That is coaching. Now imagine the coach spends every interview talking about the player’s demographic category while the player is trying to tell him he can hit a curveball. Eventually the kid might ask whether anybody has noticed the bat in his hands.
The trouble with racial preferences, wherever they are used, is not simply the question of who receives them. It is what the arrangement teaches everyone in the room. A student who works hard and earns his place may have to wonder whether others see his achievement or assume that a preference helped him. Another applicant may wonder whether the same rules applied. Those are reasons to demand clarity about the standards, not conclusions about what happened in this particular program.
I want young people to have confidence in their own abilities.
That confidence does not come from being told that standards are unfair whenever the results are disappointing. It comes from learning what is required, receiving the instruction and support to meet it, and discovering through experience that effort and preparation can change an outcome. The standard gives the work its meaning. Take away the standard, or make people suspect that it changes depending on who is being measured, and you weaken the very achievement you claim to celebrate.
This is especially important in education because today’s graduate student may become tomorrow’s teacher, professor, or administrator. What happens when a system organized around identity produces the people who will organize the next system? The categories become a habit. The habit becomes an expectation. Eventually a school can spend so much time asking whether its staff looks right that it has less energy left for the question parents care about: Can this teacher help my child learn?
A good teacher can recognize a child’s circumstances without reducing the child to those circumstances. The student who arrives behind may need additional instruction. The student who has mastered the material may need a harder assignment. The child whose family needs help navigating the school may need a conversation. Those are individual human beings with individual needs. You do not have to pretend they are all alike. You do have to care enough to see more than the box somebody checked on a form.
I have spent a great deal of my life around arguments about what Black Americans supposedly need in order to succeed. Too often, the people making those arguments seem more comfortable discussing our obstacles than our capabilities. Obstacles matter. So does the message we send when every discussion of accomplishment begins with an explanation of why the person accomplishing it needed a special arrangement. There is a difference between removing a genuine barrier and making someone’s identity the permanent centerpiece of his résumé.
The institutions named in the complaint should answer the questions being asked.
How are participants selected? What benefits follow from participation? Do university officials apply the same principles they would apply if they were recruiting applicants directly? The Justice Department can examine the evidence and determine what the law requires. We don’t need to declare the case decided to insist that the public is entitled to clear answers.
Beyond this particular complaint is a larger choice for the country. We can help people acquire knowledge, sharpen their skills, and compete for opportunities. Or we can keep building elaborate systems that sort Americans into groups and then call the sorting progress. The first approach demands work from students and institutions alike. The second gives administrators an impressive vocabulary and an apparently inexhaustible supply of meetings.
In America, Act Your Age, I argue that adulthood requires us to take responsibility for results rather than seek comfort in labels. Education ought to prepare people for that responsibility. Help the student find the door, teach him how to open it, and expect him to bring his best when he walks through. Then give him the dignity of being recognized for what he does.
