1.7 Trillion Dollars Spent: Attendance Optional.

If you can’t make it to work, call a coworker and ask him to punch you in.

Then explain to your boss that you weren’t absent. You were present by proxy. Let me know how that goes. If it works, ask whether you can sign for $1.7 trillion while you’re at it. The United States House of Representatives managed the second part on December 23, 2022.

The official tally was 225 yes, 201 no, one present and four not voting. That’s 427 members who recorded a vote or marked themselves present. Here’s the number you’ll want to read twice: 226 did it by proxy.

That’s more members voting by proxy than voted yes. Those aren’t the same groups, by the way. A proxy can cast a no vote, too. The point is that more than half the House took part without being there, and there weren’t enough members physically in the chamber to make a quorum. The Fifth Circuit ruled Friday, November 20, in a 9–8 decision, that the Constitution doesn’t let the House count absent members as present to get around that problem.

There were 431 sitting members at the time. It took 216 to make a quorum.

Notice how close that is to another number on the roll call: 216 Democrats voted yes, joined by nine Republicans. That’s enough votes to tell you who wanted the bill. It isn’t enough to tell you who was in the room. Washington would like you to glance at the first number, assume the second question was taken care of and go back to wrapping Christmas presents.

To be fair, this started in May 2020, when people had a real reason to worry about gathering in a crowded room due to covid. The House adopted a rule that let an absent member designate a colleague to cast a vote on his or her behalf. I understand why somebody quarantined at home would want their district to have a say. I’m more interested in who decided that recording that person’s vote and recording that person’s physical attendance were effectively the same transaction.

But by Christmas 2022, the Democratic-led House was using that emergency rule to pass a $1.7 trillion bill. Funny how the emergency procedures always seem to make it through the holidays.

The Senate had passed the package 68–29 the day before. Biden signed it on December 29. That was the week the whole thing went from a proposal to federal law. If you’re the House, there’s a temptation to look at the Senate vote, look at the calendar and decide everybody already knows how this ends. But the House gets its own vote because the Constitution gives it its own job. If the other chamber’s work were enough, we could save ourselves the trouble and have the Senate send over a Christmas card.

Rep. Chip Roy of Texas asked the obvious question on the House floor that day.

How was a quorum present if 226 members had voted by proxy? The presiding Democrat, Rep. G.K. Butterfield, pointed him right back to the House rule. It counted proxies toward the quorum, so under that rule there was one. That answer tells you how the House got the number. It doesn’t tell you how the House got the authority. If Congress can settle a constitutional question by writing down its preferred answer, why bother giving it a Constitution? Just give it a whiteboard.

The federal government defended the law in court. One of its arguments was that judges should treat the signed, enrolled bill as conclusive proof that Congress did its job. Judge Cory Wilson’s majority opinion drew a sensible distinction: nobody disputed which text the House voted on or whether the bill carried the proper signatures. The House’s own record showed how it counted the quorum. The question was whether the Constitution permitted that method. The dissent disagreed, arguing in part that the Quorum Clause doesn’t expressly say members have to be physically present. The majority read the clause alongside its history and an 1892 Supreme Court decision. It also left open a question this case didn’t present: whether a member participating in real time by video could count. There was no need to rule on a video call. A colleague voting in your place is a different thing.

Now, before anybody starts calculating their share of a $1.7 trillion refund, keep your calculator in the drawer.

The court did not cancel the spending package. It upheld an injunction that prevents the federal government from enforcing one provision, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against the State of Texas. The law generally requires covered employers to make reasonable accommodations for workers with pregnancy-related limitations, unless doing so would impose an undue hardship. The order isn’t a nationwide repeal, and it doesn’t by itself exempt a private employer in Texas. A worker who needs a stool or an extra bathroom break didn’t write the House attendance rule. She’s the one whose protections ended up in court because Congress put them in this bill and passed it this way.

Moving on. Americans know what it means to have to be somewhere. You can’t send a note to the factory saying Mike will operate the press for both of you. If the school calls because your kid is sick, the principal isn’t looking for a letter certifying that you’re in the parking lot. And I suspect the House could summon a physical quorum in a hurry if the vote were to give each member a cut of the $1.7 trillion. They’d find parking. They’d find child care. Somebody would fly commercial.

Before Congress spends another trillion dollars, I’d like it to do something my first-grade teacher managed without an appropriation. Take attendance.

 

Copy */
Back to top button